QR Joghary Sot Tóraghasy Q.Mәmiy, 

QR Bas prokurory A.Dauylbaevqa

Ashyq hat

Et búzylsa túz sebersin, Sot búzylsa...

Qúrmetti myrzalar!

Sizder – Qazaqstan Respublikasynyng Ata Zanynyng qatang saqtalyp, azamattardyng erkin ómir sýrip, elde әdildikting saltanat qúruynyng negizgi kepilisizder. Eger de elimizdegi zandardyng oryndaluyn tolyq talap etsenizder – halyqtyng zangha degen qúrmeti kýsheyeri sózsiz. Azamattarymyz tek zanmen jýrip, barlyq tuyndaghan mәseleni zandy jolmen shesher edi.

Al, sol zandy talap etetin prokurorlar men daugha qazylyq jasaytyn sottardyng ózderi zandy búzyp jatsa, ózgeden ne kýtuge bolady?! Elde qylmystyng sany kóbeyip, jemqorlyqtyng azaymauy – zannyng oryndalmay otyrghanynyng belgisi. Qazirgi kezde halyqtyng qúq qorghau oryndarynan góri, jurnalistterge jýginip әdildik súrauy jiyilep barady. Býgingi mening hatyma arqau bolyp otyrghan mәsele de osynday jaghday.

Jaqynda maghan Manghystau oblysy, Qaraqiya audanynyng azamaty Tenel Núrshabaev kelip, ózining zansyz júmystan shygharylghanyn, enbek qúqyn qorghau ýshin sotqa shaghymdanghanyn, biraq sottan da әdildik taba almaghandyghyn aityp aryzyn gazet arqyly sizderge jetkizudi ótingen bolatyn. Qarapayym júmysshynyng ótinishin sizderge joldap otyrmyn. Tóreligin aityp, әdil baghasyn berersizder degen senimdemin.

Núrshabaev Tenel «ManghystauMúnayGaz» AQ-na jaldanbaly «Oyl Transport Korporeyshen» JShS-nde 12 jyldan beri jýrgizushi bolyp júmys jasaghan. 2013.06.17 kýni mekeme basshysynyng №801/k  búiryghymen júmystan shygharylghan. T.Núrshabaev ózining enbek qúqyn qorghau ýshin sotqa shaghymdanghan.

2013 jyly 18 qarashada Aqtau qalalyq soty bolyp ony № 2 qalalyq sottyng sudiyasy G.Sh.Sahanova  jýrgizip, sotqa qalalyq prokurordyng kómekshisi  J.Qayyrmaghanbetova jәne eki jaqtyng senimdi ókilderi qatysady. Mekemening júmysshysyna qoyar kinәsi – «2013 jyly 30, 31, nauryz jәne 1 sәuir aralyghynda zansyz júmysta bolmaghan» deydi. Al, talapker T.Núrshabaev әlgi kýnderde júmysta bolghanyn, ol kýnderge mekemeden jalaqy alghanyn naqty dәleldermen kórsetken jәne kuәlerin algha tartqan. Júmys berushi enbek tәrtibi búzylghan kýnnen keyin 2 ay 16 kýn ótken song № 801/k búiryqpen T.Núrshabaevty  júmystan shygharghan. Búl jaghday Enbek turaly zannyng 74,73-baptaryna qayshy әreket bolyp esepteledi.Zanda enbek tәrtibi búzylghan kýnnen bastap bir ay merizimning ishinde shara qoldanuy kerek delingen. Osy bapty basshylyqqa alghan Aqtau qalalyq soty talapker T.Núrshabaevty júmysqa qayta qabyldaugha, lajsyz júmystan bos jýrgen kýnderining ortasha jalaqysyn tóleuge, moralidyq shyghynyn óteuge sheshim shygharghan.

Aqtau qalalyq sotynyng búl sheshimine qanaghattanbaghan «Oyl Transport Korporeyshen» JShS mekemesi oblystyq apelasiyalyq sotqa aryzdanady. Júmys berushi jauapkerding shaghymy boyynsha 2013.12.18 kýni Aqtau qalasynda apelasiyalyq sot bolady. Sotty sudiya B.Sh.Shoqanova jýrgizip, oghan prokuror E.Z.Dýisenbaev qatysady. Sotta memlekettik qadaghalaushy prokuror E.Z.Dýisenbaev qalalyq sottyng sheshimin ózgerusiz qaldyruyn súraydy. Apelasiyalyq sot Aqtau qalalyq sotynyng sheshimin kýshinde qaldyrady.

 Búdan song «Oyl Transport Korporeyshen» JShS  mekemesi oblystyq kassasiyalyq sotqa shaghymdanady. Kassasiyalyq sot 2014 jyly 19 aqpanda bolady. Búl sotty Manghystau oblystyq sotynyng tóraghasy D.S.Ámirov jýrgizedi. Sot alqa sudiyalary N.P.Túrjanov, A.A.Molbaeva, prokuror E.S.Berdibekov qatysady. Kassasiyalyq sot alqasy búrynghy qalalyq jәne apellyasiyalyq sottardyng sheshimin ózgerissiz qaldyryp, jauapkerding aryzyn qanaghattanghysyz qaldyrady.

Arada bir apta ótken son 2014.02.26 kýni Manghystau oblystyq prokuroturasynyng basqarma prokurory E.Dýisenbaev, Manghystau oblystyq sotynyng kassasiyalyq sot alqasyna narazylyq bildiredi. (Prokuror E.Dýisenbaev osy is boyynsha apelasiyalyq sotqa qatysyp, qalalyq sottyng kýshinde qaldyruyn súraghan bolatyn).

 2014 jyly 12 nauryzda Manghystau oblystyq sotynyng kassasiyalyq sot alqasy bir is boyynsha ekinshi ret ótedi. Kassasiyalyq sottyng qúramyna tóraghalyq etushi sudiya A.A.Molbaeva, Alqa mýsheleri N.P.Túrjanova,  H.Sh.Kajenova. Manghystau oblysy prokurorynyng orynbasary E.S.Berdibekov jәne eki jaqtyng senimdi ókilderi qatysady. Búl sot búrynghy sottardyng sheshimderining kýshin joyyp, talapker T.Núrshabaevtyng aryzyn qanaghattandyrusyz qaldyrady. Prokurordyng kassasiyalyq narazylyghyn qanaghattandyryp beredi. Zandy qadaghalaushy prokurorlar men әdil qazylar osylaysha óz sheshimderin ózderi búzady. Aldynghy sottyng sheshimin ózgertetindey dәlel, jana aighaqtar bolghan joq.  Prokuror E.Dýisenbaevtyng narazylyq shaghymy jauapker mekemening birininshi kassasiyalyq sotqa bergen aryzymen birdey eshbir ózgerissiz, jana dәlelderi de joq. Talapker T.Núrshabaev sotqa jogharydan «tapsyrma» berilgen bolar dep esepteydi. Olay bolmasa, sottar óz sheshimderin ózderi búzbas edi. Búghan kýmәn keltiretin sebepterimiz de bar.

Birinshiden, Búl is 2014.02.19 kýni kassasiyalyq sot alqasynda qaralyp, talqylanyp sheshim shygharghan. Kassasiyalyq sottyng sheshimi kýshine engennen keyin, arada bir ay ótpey jatyp 2014.03.12 kýni qayta kassasiyalyq alqa soty bolyp, aldynghy sot qaulylaryna qarsy sheshim shyghardy. Osy zandy ma? Kassasiyalyq sot alqasynyng sheshimin tek qana Joghary Sot  búzbay ma?!

Ekinshiden, kassasiyalyq shaghymdy da, kassasiyalyq narazylyqty da,  sudiya A.Molbaeva qaraghan. Birinshi sotta is boyynsha bayandamashy bolsa, ekinshisinde әri bayandamashy, әri tóraghalyq jasady. Osy zandy ma?

Ýshinshiden, oblys prokurorynyng orynbasary E.Berdibekov birinshi kassasiyalyq sotta qalalyq sottyng sheshimin ornynda qaldyrudy súraghan, ekinshi narazylyq kassasiyalyq sotta qalalyq sottyng sheshimin búzudy súraydy. Al prokuror E.Dýisenbaev osy is boyynsha apelyasiyalyq sotta Aqtau qalalyq sottyng sheshimin qoldaghan. 2 aidan keyin kerisinshe kassasiyalyq narazylyq jazghan. Sot sheshimi zansyz bolsa búrynghy sotta nege narazylyq bildirmegen?!

Osylaysha adal enbegimen kýn kórip otyrghan qarapayym júmysshy óz qúqyn zang jolymen qorghay almady. Elimizdegi júmyssyzdar qataryna 52 jastaghy Tenel de qosyldy. Endi júmystan quylghan «shaldy» kim júmysqa alady? Qazymyr basshylardyn, solqyldaq sottyng kesirinen qazaqtyng bir shanyraghy kýneltis kózinen, balalary jep otyrghan nanynan aiyryldy. Sonda búl sotta kim jendi, kim jenildi? Áriyne, qarapayym júmysshy jenildi. Kim jendi? Múnay kompaniyasynyng qojayyndary jendi. Kimdi jendi? Óz júmysshysyn!..

Sonda qarapayym Qazaqstan azamatynyng zandy qúqyn kim qorghaydy? Halyq kimge senedi? Sotqa ma? Sottar óz shygharghan sheshimderin ózderi zansyz búzyp otyrghan joq pa?..

Qúrmetti zanger myrzalar!

Songhy kezderi múnday oqighalar jiyilep barady. Halyq әdilettikti zannan taba almasa, basqa qaydan tabady?! Sottar men prokurlargha sabaq, qarapayym halyqqa ýmit, Ata Zangha qúrmet, memleketke senim bolu ýshin búl iske әdil sheshim qabyldaularynyzdy súraymyn. «Et búzylsa túz sebersin, túz búzylsa ne sebersin» degen maqaldy úmytpalyq myrzalar!..

Jәnibek Qojyq

Manghystau oblysy