Jazylghan jaydyng jalghasy

Jazylghan jaydyng jalghasy

Qúrmetti redaksiya! "Jas Alash" qashanda әlimjettikting qúrbandaryna qol úshyn sozudan jәne qazaqtyng mýddesin qorghaudan jazbaushy edi. Men advokat retinde "Jas Alash" oqyrmandaryn kelesi jaghdaylardan habardar etkim keledi. Búl mәselede "kýshtining әlsizge tize batyruy da", últymyzdyng mýddesi de bar dep bilemin. Jәne bir aitqym keletini - biz óz tarapymyzdan әreket jasamasaq ta, gazetting búdan búrynghy sandarynda men kótergeli otyrghan mәsele turasynda 2 birdey maqala jariyalandy. Olar - "Saqaldylar men shendiler tartysy" jәne "Ismatulla biylikke talasudan aulaq" - dep atalady. Ózderiniz kórip jýrgendey, qazir para alyp jatyp ústalghan shendiler, sybaylas jemqorlyq ayasynda isti bolghan ministrler taghy da basqa shekpendilerding ókilderi baspasóz-konferensiyalaryn ótkizip, búqaralyq aqparat qúraldaryn shulatyp-aq jatady. Onday oy bizde de bolghan. Alayda, osy mәselening basty "ayyptalushysy" Ismatulla aqsaqal (ol kisi­ning jasy jetpiske kelgendikten aqsaqal dep otyrmyn) "Qaraqan basymyzdyng qamy ýshin, el ishin dýrliktiruding qajeti joq" dep toqtatyp qoyghan bolatyn. Sóitip, ýn-týnsiz, yn-shynsyz tergeu isi ayaqtalugha tayaghan kezde, 20 sәuir kýni "Habar" arnasy býkil elge "Aqiy­qat" degen aty bar, alayda "zaty" joq, yaghny kim týsirgeni bel­gisiz eshbir derek-dәieksiz, ósek pen jaladan túratyn "derekti filimin" kórsetti. Barlyghymyzdyng shydamymyzdyng jetken jeri osy boldy. Sol sebepti, osy bir shiyelenisti isting basy-qasynda jýrgen maman-zanger retinde qylmystyq isting naq­ty jay-japsaryn "Jas Alash" arqyly jariyalaghym keldi. Mening qorghauymdaghy Ismatulla Abdughappar men Sayat Ibraev jәne basqa da bir top azamattargha qarsy qylmystyq is 2010 jyldyng tamyz aiynda qozghaldy. Sol kezden bastap, atalghan adamdar qamauda jatyr. Qazirgi kezde qozghalghanyna 9 ay ótkende, tergeu amaldary ayaqta­lyp, is Almaty qalasynyng prokurory men sotyna joldandy.

QR Konstitusiyasynyng jәne QR QIJK-ning 19-babyna sәikes, әr adam onyng qylmys jasaghany ýshin kinәliligi zanda kórsetilgen tәrtip­pen dәleldengenge jәne sottyng zandy kýshine engen ýkimimen belgilengenge deyin kinәsiz dep sanalady. "Habar" telearnasynda kórse­tilgen derekti filim - sot bolar aldynda kórsetilgendikten, sotta qazylyq etetin alqa biyler ýshin   aiyptalushylar turaly aldyn ala jaghymsyz pikir qalyptastyryp otyr. Ayta ketetin mәsele, sot alqa biyleri kәsiby zangerler emes, qarapayym adamdar, әrtýrli mamandyq iyeleri, al sot ýkimi solardyng kóp­shilik dauys beruine baylanysty shygharylady. Zandy bylay qoyyp, kýndelikti tәjiriybede bayqalatynday, kez kelgen qylmystyq hronikada qylmys jasady degen kýdikti adamnyng tolyq aty-jóni atalmaydy jәne isting mәn-jayy aitylmaydy. Al búl jerde "Habar" telearnasy onyng bәrin bylay qoyyp, tipti qylmystyq is materialdarynda joq mәlimetterdi de aiyptalushylar jasady dep kórsetip jibergen.  Eger derekti filimdi kórgen bolsanyzdar, onda bir top adamnyng jerde jatqan adamdy tepkilep jat­qan kórinisi beriledi jәne Aydyn esimdi azamatty óltirdi dep, onyng denesin basqa bir óz ajalynan ólmegen adamnyng denesimen almastyryp qoyghan-mys degen derekter keltirilgen. Mening qorgha­uymdaghy azamattargha qatysty qylmystyq isti tergeu amaldary 7 sәuir 2011 jyly ayaqtaldy. Alayda onday faktiler qylmystyq is materialdarynda joq, yaghny ol derekter bo­yynsha mening qorghauymdaghy azamattargha eshqanday aiyp taghylmaghan. Biraq baghdarlama naqty "Senim. Bilim. Ómir" RQB-ne qa­tys­ty, olardyng jetekshilerine qar­sy qozghalghan qylmystyq is negi­zinde týsirilgendikten filimdi kór­gen kórermen, әriyne, osynyng bәrin birlestikting adamdary jasady degen oigha qalady. Sonda jurnalist atal­ghan derekterdi qaydan jәne qanday jolmen alghan jәne osy derekterdi kórsetudegi maqsaty ne? Negizinde QR QIJK-ning 80-baby, QR Azamattyq kodeksining talaptaryna sәikes - qaytys bolghan adamnyng nemese jәbirlenushining zandy ókili bolyp birinshi kezekte onyng zandy nekede túrghan joldasy bolyp tabylady. Qaytys bolghan adam Aydyn Tilejanovtyng әieli Sandughash Qiqymbaeva bolsa, ózining búl oqighagha esh qatysy joq ekenin aitady. Eng óreskeli, vedomstvoaralyq tergeu tobynyng qyzmetkerleri Aydynnyng denesin eshbir tuystaryna, onyng ishinde zandy ókili bolyp tabylatyn Sandughashqa da eskertpesten, ziratyn búzu arqyly alyp ketken. Sol arqyly QR QIJK-ning 225-babynyng 3-tarmaghy, 244-babynyng talaptary óreskel týrde búzyl­ghan.

Yaghny jәbirlenushining ókilin ziratty búzyp, deneni alatynyn aldyn ala eskertpegen, saraptama taghayyndau turaly qaulymen tanystyrmaghan. Men zanger retinde búl mәselening tergeushiler tarapynan prosessualdyq tәrtipting qanshalyqty óreskel búzylghanyn tilge tiyek etip otyrmyn. Al adamger­shilik, moralidyq túrghydan alyp qaraghanda, Aydynnyng joldasy Sandughashqa, basqa tuystaryna osy jaghdaylardyng barlyghy qalay әser etetini oilastyryldy ma? Nege "Habar" telearnasynyng jurnaliys­teri býkil elge jariya etpey túryp, osy jaghyn oilastyrmady? Bizding qolymyzdaghy mәlimetterge qaraghanda, jurnalister tek qana tergeu toby neni núsqasa, sony týsirgen siyaqty, óitkeni barlyq jerde olardy polisiya qyzmetkerleri ertip jýrgen. Qazirgi kezde, mәiitting orny әli oisyrap jatyr, deneni qazyp alyp ketken tergeu tobynyng qyz­met­kerleri, ony keri kómip retke keltirudi oilaryna da almaghan. Osy zang búzushylyqtar boyynsha Sandughash ÚQK-ge aryz joldaghan. Jәne bir aitpaghym, filimde sóz sóilegen vedomstvoaralyq tergeu tobynyng jetekshisi, IIM-ning bas­qarma bastyghy, polisiya pol­kov­niygi M.Qúmarbekov óz óndi­risindegi qylmystyq iske bayla­nys­ty, "Býgingi kýnge deyin QR au­maghynda auyr jәne asa auyr qylmystargha qatysy bar degen kýdik­pen top jetekshisi Ismatulla Abdughappar jәne toptyng 6 belsendi mýshesi qamaugha alyndy" dep súh­bat be­redi. Alayda naqty ne ýshin aiyptalyp otyrghandary turaly tis jarmady. Tergeu tobynyng jetekshisi M.Qúmarbekovting "Senim. Bilim. Ómir" jetekshilerin auyr, asa auyr qylmystarmen aiyptauy, aldyn ala teledidar arqyly ol turaly filim úiymdastyruy - advokat retinde mening qorghauymdaghy azamattardy әldekimder ýshin qoghamgha asa qauipti adamdar retinde kórsetuge tyrysqan әreket degen oigha qaldyrdy.

Bayqasanyzdar, bir kýnning ishinde, yaghny 2010 jyldyng 21 tamyzy kýni bir adamnyng (E.Mahambetova) aryzy boyynsha, odan búryn­ghy Almaty qalasy Týrksib audandyq IIB qylmystyq is qozghau­dan bas tartu turaly qaulysy Bas prokuraturanyng búiryghymen búzylyp, sol kýni IIM-ne joldanyp, sol kýni Mahambetova E., QR Qarjy polisiya Agenttigine aryz joldap, ol sol kýni QR IIM-ge joldanyp, QR IIM-de sol kýni QR QK-nin  126-baby, 2 bóligimen qylmystyq is qozghalyp, Ismatulla Abdughappar qamaugha alynyp, sol kýni, IIM-ning 43 adamynan túratyn tergeu jәne jedel uәkil qyzmetkerleri tergeu júmystaryna kirisip ýlgeredi. Sensenizder, osynyng bәri bir kýn­ning ishinde, yaghny 21 tamyz 2010 jy­ly bolady. Keyinnen, 25.08.2010 j., ýsh birdey Respublikalyq den­geydegi mekemeler - ishki ister miy­nistrligi, Qarjy polisiyasy jәne ÚQK qyzmetkerlerinen túratyn jýzden astam vedomstvoaralyq jedel-tergeu toby iske kirisedi. Búghan deyingi elimizding qylmystyq is jýrgizu tarihynda ishki ister organdary qyzmetkerlerining bir nashaqordyng aryzy boyynsha osynshalyqty jedel qimyldaghanyn esti­gen­deriniz bar ma? Osy jaghdaylar meni ghana emes, iske qatysy bar adam­dardy da - qylmystyq is arnayy tapsyryspen jýzege asyrylyp jatyr degen oigha iytermeleydi, al nashaqordyng aryzy soghan syltau ghana bolghan.  Mening qorghauymdaghy azamattardyng qanday auyr jәne asa auyr qylmystar jasaghandary ýshin     aiyptalyp otyrghandary "Habar" arnasynyng kórermenderi, jalpy qogham ýshin qyzyqty bolar dep esepteymin. Shyndyghyna kelgende, mening qorghauymdaghy azamattar qoghamgha paydaly isteri ýshin aiyptalyp otyr. Endi osylargha qysqasha toqtala ketsem. Birinshi aiyptaulary - QR QK-ning 126-bap, 3-bólimi, yaghny adamnyng bas bostandyghynan eriksiz aiyru. Búl jiyrma shaqty nashaqorlar men araqqa tәueldi adamdardyng aryzy boyynsha qozghaldy. Ayta ketu kerek, osy aryz iyeleri, yaghny jәbirle­nu­shilerding kópshiligi keyinnen tergeu organdarynan óz aryzdaryn qayta aldy.

Sebebi, olardyng basym kópshiligi búrynghy ziyandy әdette­rinen arylyp, qazirgi kezde qalypty ómir sýrude. Mysaly, osy qylmystyq is ayasynda Týrkistandaghy ruhany ortalyqqa ishki ister organdarynyng qyzmet­ker­leri ayaq asty tekserumen kelgen kezde, onda otyrghan elu shaqty adamnyng tek qana 3-eui aryz jazady, qalghandary aryz jazudan ýzildi-kesildi bas tartady. Ayta ketetin taghy bir mәsele, ózining qyzmet etken songhy 10 jyl kóle­min­de osy ruhany ortalyqtan jogharyda atalghan jiyrma shaqty emes, myndaghan esirtkige jәne araqqa tәueldi adamdar jazylyp shyqqan bolatyn jәne olardyng ózderi men tuystarynyng Ismatulla Abdughappargha al­ghystan basqa aitary joq. Olardyng kópshiligi tipti qylmystyq is shenberinde kuә retinde jauaptal­ghan da bolatyn. Qylmystyq qúqyq­ta - qylmystyng subiektiyv­tik jaghy degen bolady. Yaghny ol - qylmys jasady degen adamnyng sol qylmysty jasaudaghy oiy, maqsaty. Eger kýdikti adam óz әreketin qylmys jasau ýshin emes, jaqsylyq, adam­gershilik túrghyda jasaghany dәleldense, ol qylmystyq jauap­ker­shilikten bosatylady. Yaghny mening aitpaghym Ismatulla Abdughappar eldegi býkil nashaqor men araqqa tәueldi adamdardy jay ghana qamap ústau ýshin jinaghan joq qoy, olardy emdep aqsha tappaghany da tergeu­men anyqtalyp otyr. Ol kisi nashaqorlar men araqqa tәuel­dilerdi "zikir ghibadaty" arqyly emdeudi maqsat tútty jәne ol emi teoriyalyq túrghyda әli zerttelip, anyqtalmasa da, is jýzinde óz jemisin berdi de. Sonda ol adamdy biz ne ýshin, qanday qylmystyq oiy, maqsaty ýshin sottamaqpyz? Ekinshi taqqan auyr qylmystary, qylmystyq úiym qúru jәne basqaru, yaghny QR QK-ning 235-baby, 2-bólimi. Ádette úiymdasqan qylmystyq top degen kezde bizding esimizge osy kezge deyin sot ýkimimen sottalghan "4 aghayyndy", "Qyryqbaevtar", "Ryjiy Almaz" taghy bas­­qalary siyaqty, búryn birneshe mәrte sottalghan, múzday qarulan­ghan, adamdardy tonap jәne óltirgen qaraqshylar týsedi. Osy jerde eskere keter bir jayt, kez kelgen qylmystyq toptyng negizgi maqsaty bireu - ol asa kóp kólemde aqsha, qarajat tabu. Bizding jaghdayda taghylghan aiyp olardyng barlyghynan da asyp týsti. Sebebi qylmystyq úiym qúru degenimiz - úiymdasqan qylmystyq top qúrugha qaraghanda әldeqayda, kýrdeli, әri belsendi qúrylymdyq kýsh, onyng ishinde bir emes, birneshe úiymdasqan qylmys­tyq top boluy shart.  Alayda tergeu barysynda "Se­nim. Bilim. Ómir" qoghamdyq birles­tiginen, bolmasa onyng jetek­shisi men belsendi mýshelerine tiyesili eshqanday qúndy mýlik, qarajat, bolmasa ýlken kólemde qaru tabylghan joq. Shetelge qarjy audaru nemese ol jaqtan qarjy alu siyaqty birde-bir fakt tirkel­megen. Olardyng eshqaysysynyng tipti banktik esepshottary da bolmaghan. Sonda aqshasy, qaru-jaraghy, basqalay da kýshtik qúrylymdargha tәn belgileri joq ol ne qylghan qylmystyq úiym, yaghny sindikat?   Ýshinshi jәne eng negizgisi - ol, zansyz diny ekstremistik jәne qoghamdyq birlestikter qúryp, azamattardyng arasynda diny alauyzdyq tughyzdy degen aiyptaulary. Osy jerge Sizderding basa nazar audarularynyzdy súraymyn. Birinshiden, "Senim.Bilim.Ómir" RQB zansyz qúrylghan joq. Ol osydan 9 jyl búryn zandy týrde Respublikalyq qoghamdyq birlestik bolyp әdilet organdarynda tirkelgen jәne kýni býginge deyin ózining zandy qyzmetin jalghastyryp kele jat­qan úiym. Múnday úiymdy zansyz jәne ekstremistik dep tanu ýshin "Ekstremizmge qarsy kýres turaly" QR Zanynyng 1-babynyn,  6-tarmaghyna sәikes, zandy kýshine engen sot sheshimi bolu kerek. Maghan kýni býginge deyin belgilisi - sot sheshimi­men ekstremistik dep ta­nyl­ghan 14 úiym bar, (Taliban, Hizbut-tahrir t.b.) biraq olardyng ishinde "Senim. Bilim. Ómir" RQB joq. Odan qala berdi mening qolymda 2005 jylghy zandy kýshine engen sot sheshimi bar. Oghan sәikes, "Senim. Bilim. Ómir" RQB-in ekstre­miys­tik úiym dep tanu turaly Manghystau oblystyq IID-ning talap aryzy tolyqtay qanaghattandyrusyz qaldyrylghan.

Sondyqtan da eshkimning de búl qoghamdyq bir­lestikti jәne oghan qatysy bar adamdardy ekstremister dep atauyna, eshqanday qúqyghy joq!  Ekinshiden, qanday dinder arasynda alauyzdyq tughyzghany anyqtalmaghan. Tergeu ayasynda jýrgizil­gen saraptama qorytyndylaryna sәikes, "Senim. Bilim. Ómir" RQB-ning jәne "ABJaD" intellektualdyq tanym kluby óz qyzmetin jýrgizu barysynda - Islam dinining uahhabiylik dep atalatyn baghytyn ústanushylardyng diny nanymy men senimderin qorlaghan! Eger uahha­bizmning elimizge tiygizetin ziyany turaly әngimeler men naqty tarihy derekterdi aitu qylmys bolyp sanalatyn bolsa, onda mening qorgha­uymdaghy azamattar óz qylmystaryn tolyq moyyndaugha dayyn. Sebebi, ol azamattar atalghan diny baghyttyng ziyandyghy turaly zertteu­lerin osy kezge deyin jay ghana emes, ghylymy týrde negizdep kelgen bolatyn. Jәne olar ózderining búl kózqarastarynan eshqashan taymaq emes. Odan basqa, tergeu organdarynyng búl aiyptary sottan qoldau tabatyn bolsa, onda elimizdegi jurnalister men sayasatkerlerding bi­razy qylmysty bolyp shyqpay ma? Mysaly, tehnika ghylymdarynyng doktory, professor Sayat Ibraevqa osy aiyp ne ýshin taghylghanyna toqtalayyn, sensenizder de, senbe­senizder de eki auyz sózi (fraza) ýshin;

1. "Biz týrikke de, arabqa da elik­temeuimiz kerek, qazaqtyng óz joly bar", 2. "Eshkim meshitke bar­ghanda salafit bolayyn, vahabit bolayyn ne basqa da "iyt" bolayyn dep barmaydy. Ol bir qúdaydy izdep barady", boldy, bas-ayaghy osy. Osy eki auyz sózin sarapshylar (sózbe-sóz) "Keltirilgen ýzindide diny alauyzdyq pen arazdyqty tudyrudyng belgileri - is-әreketterine jaghymsyz bagha beru arqyly vahhabizm, salafizm aghymy ókilderining teris-jaghymsyz obrazdaryn qalyptastyru, atalghan diny aghym ókil­derine әdeby til normalaryn saqtaghan, biraq qoghamdyq-izgilik qaghidalaryna qayshy keletin sózder tobyndaghy eki týrli maghynada: 1. Salafizm, vahabizm ókil­derin zat esimdi zoosemantikalyq metafora retinde qasqyr túqymdas sýt qo­rek­ti ýy januaryna teneu;

2. Auyspaly maghynada "Onbaghan, jauyz" syn esim sózi retinde olargha asa aiqyn teris jaghymsyz bagha beru bar" dep, qorytyndy berip, tergeu toby atalghan qorytyndygha sәikes, Sayat Ibraevqa QR QK-ning 164-babymen (diny alauyzdyq tughyzu) aiyp taghady. Búl saraptamanyng jәne aiyptyng negizsiz ekenin filologiya ghylymdarynyng doktory, professor A.Salqynbay tolyq dәleldep berdi. Osy orayda taghy bir aita kete­tin mәsele - ol qoghamdyq bir­lestikting óz qyzmetin ashyq jýrgiz­genine toqtalghym keledi. Yaghny "Senim. Bilim. Ómir" RQB mýsheleri elimizding barlyq aimaghyna baryp vahhabizm men salafizm turaly jәne diniy-últtyq ekstremizge qatysty leksiyalar oqydy, ashyq pikirtalastar jýrgizdi, eng qyzyghy osy qyzmetterining barlyghy da tiyisti organdardyng aldyn ala rúqsaty, kelisimi arqyly jýrgizildi. Birles­tik tarapynan eshqanday jasyryn júmystar atqarylghan emes. Oghan dәlel - bizding qolymyzdaghy kóptegen foto jәne beynematerialdar. Onda birlestik qatysqan, ne bolmasa úiymdastyrghan jinalystarda qúqyq qorghau organdary, prokuratura, ishki sayasat, әdilet organdary, kóptegen jurnalisterding qatysuymen bolghan. Meni tanghaldyratyny - osynsha jyl kóleminde óz júmysyn qaltqysyz atqaryp kelgen jәne negizgi júmysynyng baghyty ekstremizmmen kýres dep ta­nyl­ghan qoghamdyq birlestikting ózi­ning qyzmeti ayaq astynan - ekstre­miys­tik dep tanylghany, yaghny sol bo­yynsha qylmystyq is qozghalghany. Advokat retinde meni tanghaldyratyn jәne bir jaghday - uahha­bitterding diny nanym-senimin qorlaghan dep qylmystyq is qozghaghanymen, is boyynsha birde-bir sol din ókilining aryzynyng bolmauy! Yaghny QR qylmystyq is jýrgizu kodeksi­ning talaptaryna sәikes, tergeu tobynyng olardy jәbirlenu­shi dep tanymauy. Sonda mening qorghauymdaghy adamdar qúqyghyn búzyp otyrghan uahhabitter degen kimder? Olardyng "Senim. Bilim. Ómir" siyaq­ty úiymdary bar ma? Bolsa, nege sol úiymdary bet-per­desin ashyp, "Senim. Bilim. Ómir" siyaqty ashyq әreket etpeydi?! Osy jәne osy sekildi súraqtar qylmystyq ispen tolyq tanysqan kez kelgen kózi ashyq jandy mazalaytyny haq. Kóre-bile túra, adam­gershilik pen zandyq prinsipterdi óreskel búzu faktileri shash etekten ekeni óz aldyna bólek әngime. Búl maqalany jazghandaghy maqsatym - bazbir solaqay, tapsyrys oryndaghysh, qarapayym kәsiby etikasynan baz keshken BAQ ókilderi qa­lyptastyra bastaghan qoghamdyq pikirdi búzu, mening qorghauymdaghy adamdardyng jazyqsyz qaralanyp, sottalyp bara jatqanyn el-júrtqa jetkizu. Al әdil sheshimdi uaqyt pen әdil sot enshisi­ne qaldyrdyq.

***

"... Teologiyalyq zertteu jýrgizgen S.Enchbay óz qorytyndysynda: "Vahabistik - salafistik "taza islam" baghyty Qazaqstan músylmandary diny basqarmasy ústanghan Ábu Hanifa mazhabyna qayshy kele me? Vahabistik-salafistik islam ishindegi diny baghytty synau nemese ony ústanghan adamdargha til tiygizu islam dinine til tiygizu bolyp sanala ma?" degen súraqqa: "Uahhabshyldyq baghyt Qazaqstan músylmandary diny basqarmasy ústanghan hanafy mazhabyna qayshy. Uahhabshyldyqty ústanghan adamdardy synau islamgha til tiygizu bolyp sanalmaydy", - dep jauap beredi. Al sot psihologiyalyq-filologiyalyq zertteu jýrgizgen G.IY.Muhataeva men D.T.Rabilov teolog ghalymnan asyp, óz salasyna qatysty emes, yaghny filologiyagha qatysty emes "diny arazdyq pen alauyzdyqty qozdyru belgileri bar" degen qorytyndy shygharady. Múnday qorytyndyny filolog sarapshylar emes, teolog sarapshylar shygharuy kerek edi. (Filologiya ghylymdarynyng doktory, professor A.B.Salqynbaydyng saraptamasynan)

***

"Aydyn óz ajalynan ólmedi, mәiiti auystyrylghan" degen aiyptau janymdy auyrtty. Qúday qosqan qosaghym marqúm Aydynnyng sýiegin qazyp alyp, tiri jangha qiyanaty joq azamattargha jala jauyp jatqanyn estigende, jýregim su ete qaldy. Jaghamdy ústadym. Aydyn súrausyz jatqan adam emes qoy, artynda bala-shaghasy, myna biz qaldyq. Nege maghan eskertpedi imansyzdar? Onysy azday, kýieuimning sýiegin әli kýnge deyin ornyna qayta kómbegen. Beyiti oirandalyp jatyr. Jala jabudan ghana túratyn "Aqiqat" degen filimsymaqty kórgende, ýidegi qyzym Biybinúr: "Ákem tiri eken ghoy, mama?! Tiri bolsa, nege bizdi izdep kelmeydi?" dep jylap, әkesin izdegende, janymdy qoyargha jer tappadym. Bala-shaghamnyng kóniline alang tughyzyp, jýregin jaralap ketti. Ásirese, enemdi, Aydynnyng anasyn ayaymyn, ony da sergeldenge salyp qoydy. Balasyn ólimge kim qisyn, ananyng aty ana emes pe?! Qayyn atam Aydynnyng mәiitin kórip, balasy ekenine kózi jetken bolatyn. Sonda bizding janymyzdy auyrtyp, aruaqty qorlaghandardyng maqsaty ne?"

(Sandughash Qiqymbaevanyng baspasóz mәslihatynda aitqany).

Abzal Qúspanov,

advokat.

http://zhasalash.kz/kogam/4759.html